Headline
ICC prosecutors seek rejection of Duterte defense request over evidence procedure
Floyd Brenz., Philippine Canadian Inquirer
November 22, 2026

Photo Courtesy: CBC News
Prosecutors at the International Criminal Court (ICC) have asked judges to reject a procedural request from former president Rodrigo Duterte’s defense team, arguing that it violates established rules on challenging evidence.
In a public redacted filing dated November 20, the Office of the Prosecutor said the defense went beyond the scope of observations requested by Trial Chamber III and improperly sought to challenge evidence before it was formally presented in court.
Acting Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang urged the chamber to dismiss the request at the outset, citing Rule 64(1) of the ICC Rules of Procedure and Evidence.
Under the rule, parties must raise objections to the admissibility of evidence when the material is formally submitted to the chamber. Prosecutors argued that Duterte’s lawyers should therefore present their concerns at that stage rather than through a separate procedural request.
The prosecution also sought to correct what it described as a mistaken submission by the defense. However, details of the disputed argument and the information involved were withheld in the public document to protect a prosecution source.
The latest dispute follows the defense team’s November 18 filing opposing the admission of previously recorded testimony from a former Davao City police officer identified as Witness P-0002.
Duterte’s lawyer, Peter Haynes, argued that prosecutors had not sufficiently established that the witness was unavailable to testify in person. The defense also questioned the reliability of the witness’s statements, citing alleged inconsistencies and the risk of unfair prejudice against the former president.
The prosecution is seeking to have the recorded testimony admitted as evidence, while the defense maintains that the witness should be called to testify orally unless his unavailability is properly established.
The ICC has yet to issue a ruling on the evidentiary dispute.
Duterte is facing crimes against humanity charges linked to killings during his administration’s anti-drug campaign and his time as Davao City mayor. His trial before the ICC in The Hague is scheduled to begin on November 30, 2026.
