Canada News
Manitoba judge halts impaired-driving case after RCMP officer conceals relationship with key witness
Floyd Brenz., Philippine Canadian Inquirer
November 19, 2026

Photo Courtesy: CBC News
A Manitoba judge has ordered a stay of proceedings in an impaired-driving case after an RCMP officer failed to disclose his romantic relationship with a nurse who became a key witness in the investigation.
The case involved a woman accused of impaired driving causing bodily harm following a serious vehicle collision near Flin Flon in March 2023. She had pleaded guilty to the charge, which carried the possibility of imprisonment, but was later allowed to withdraw her plea after the undisclosed relationship came to light.
According to the court decision, RCMP Cpl. Jordan Tost identified two nurses at the Flin Flon hospital as potential witnesses and recommended that the lead investigator interview them. One of the nurses was his romantic partner.
The relationship was not disclosed until May 2025, when Crown prosecutor Kameron Hutchinson unexpectedly encountered the officer and the nurse together at a Canadian Tire store.
Provincial Court Judge Victoria Cornick found that the omission compromised the legal process. It prevented the justice who authorized police to obtain the woman’s medical records from considering relevant information about the witness and her connection to the investigating officer.
The judge also noted that the defence had previously been denied an opportunity to cross-examine the two nurses during a 2024 hearing.
Cornick said the failure to disclose the relationship undermined the fairness of the proceedings and violated the accused woman’s Charter rights. She emphasized that the justice system cannot depend on chance encounters to uncover information that should have been disclosed.
The woman’s lawyer, Matt Gould, described the ruling as rare, saying the case raised serious concerns about police accountability and the importance of full disclosure in criminal investigations.
The judge acknowledged the seriousness of the crash and the injuries suffered by the victim but ruled that protecting the integrity of the justice system must take priority.
