Connect with us

Canada News

Which political party has the best child care plan?

Published

on

Which is better: tax credits or direct funding? When it comes to solving the problem of child care affordability for families, both alternatives are on offer in this election campaign. (File photo: Justin Trudeau/Facebook)

Which is better: tax credits or direct funding? When it comes to solving the problem of child care affordability for families, both alternatives are on offer in this election campaign. Some believe it could be the campaign’s defining issue. My analysis suggests that the Liberals have a far better plan for making child care affordable, while the Conservatives’ tax credit would have only a minor effect on affordability.

The Trudeau Liberals’ plan would provide licensed child care for $10 a day for children under six. It will require provincial-territorial co-operation and when fully developed will cost more than $9 billion annually. The NDP under Jagmeet Singh supports this direction. Erin O’Toole’s Conservatives think a tax credit for child care expenses will make any type of child care you want to use much more affordable. The Conservative plan is uncosted, but it has been suggested that it will cost about $1 billion to $2.3 billion per year.

I’ve modelled these two alternatives for Ontario and the results are fascinating. The two charts below show different measures of child care affordability for three policy situations: the current situation in Ontario; an O’Toole tax credit; and the $10-a-day plan. There’s a stunning amount of difference in how these plans would affect affordability.

I’ve taken a couple family with two children – one and three years of age – as the basis for these calculations. One parent earns 60 per cent of the family income and the other earns 40 per cent.

Figure 1 shows the per cent of after-tax family income that would be eaten up in accessing licensed child care. Figure 2 shows what’s called “caregiving parent affordability.”  It compares the cost of child care to the income gains when the caregiving parents takes up paid employment. The per cent of this earning contribution that gets eaten up in accessing licensed child care is a measure of the size of this barrier to a mother’s employment.

The blue line, highest up on both of these charts, shows the current affordability situation of Ontario families. It incorporates Premier Doug Ford’s tax credit for child care expenses that we already have in Ontario and the child care expense deduction. Most couple families do not benefit from low-income child care subsidies, so I do not consider them.

O’Toole wants to layer a federal tax credit for child care expenses on top of Ontario’s current funding programs, but also wants to get rid of the child care expense deduction and rip up the existing provincial/territorial child care agreements. In essence, he would be giving with one hand and taking away with the other. This is the green line on the charts.

The $10-a-day-program was announced in the recent federal budget. Eight provinces and territories have signed five-year agreements of major investments to lower fees immediately and reach $10-a-day by 2025. This is shown as a red line on the charts.

The first chart (“family income affordability”) shows how much after-tax family income will have to be spent on child care for a typical family. The higher up the line is, the more unaffordable child care is. In the current situation in Ontario, for a family with two children, child care is pretty much unaffordable at any level of income – accounting for 40 per cent or more of total family income at incomes below $40,000 a year, but also accounting for 20 to 30 per cent of total family income even at incomes above this level.

O’Toole’s tax credit policy (green line) would make most of these families somewhat better off.   Assuming the provincial and federal tax credits are stacked, now “only” 30 per cent or more of after-tax income would be required to pay for child care at incomes below $40,000 a year, falling to about 20 per cent of income above about $60,000.

In contrast, the $10-a-day policy (red line) would mean that families would spend just less than 5 per cent of after-tax income on child care.

The impact of these different policies on child care affordability is radically different. The O’Toole tax credit nibbles at the affordability problem, but many families would find that 20 per cent or more of their after-tax income is still too steep a price to pay. The $10-a-day Trudeau plan supported by Singh would, on the other hand, make licensed child care much more affordable for all families using it.

Figure 2 is even more revealing.  A lot of the discussion about the recovery from the pandemic and the “she-cession” has centred on getting rid of child care costs, which have been pointed to as a major barrier to women’s employment. Affordability of child care is important for individual families, of course, but the link to women’s employment makes it a particularly pressing societal issue. A lot of people believe that family decisions about whether a mother will seek employment generally involve a direct comparison between the cost of child care and the amount of extra income she can bring to the family. If the cost of child care is very large compared to her net earnings after taxes, then many mothers will decide to stay out of the workforce, at least until their children grow older (and cheaper in terms of child care costs).

Figure 2 outlines caregiving parent affordability. The blue line shows the current situation of this two-child family at different levels of income for this caregiving parent. For any caregiving parent with two children earning less than about $32,000 annually, there is no financial gain to the family from her employment; child care costs eat up more than 100 per cent of her net earnings. If she earns a lot more than this (and most mothers do not), she can drive this percentage down but child care costs will still consume the majority of her earnings.   Employment when children are young may be desirable to maintain a career, but it is not very financially beneficial.

The O’Toole tax credit would nibble at these major barriers to women’s employment. The Conservative election platform says that “[n]obody should be prevented from getting back to work because they can’t afford childcare.” It is clear that the O’Toole tax credit fails this test.

This tax credit would still leave second earners with two children who are below the median income paying more than 80 per cent of their additional earnings for child care. Even at higher income levels, most families would spend at least 50 per cent of their additional earnings to pay for child care if the second earner were employed.

With the $10-a-day plan, families will still have some child care expenses – fees for licensed child care would be about $2,600 annually per child. For lower income earners, that could still eat up 20 per cent of the contribution a second-income earner, usually the mother, makes to family income, but the fees would be much less of an employment barrier than they currently are. Child care subsidies could be re-purposed to reduce these amounts. But for many families, child care costs would be less than 20 per cent of a mother’s income and mothers who prefer to be employed would find that employment, finally, financially rewarding. Many studies find that a mother’s employment is quite sensitive to the price of child care.

My conclusion? The O’Toole tax credit nibbles at the edges of the child care affordability problem. Most families using child care would be better off, but since the plan includes no controls on future fee rises, this improvement might be temporary. On top of this, tax credits for  expenses have been reliably associated with poorer quality child care. On the other hand, the Liberal plan will have a massive impact on child care affordability and, probably, mothers’ employment.

Conservatives argue that most families will not be helped if licensed child care is made much less expensive. Recent evidence does not support this view. There are nearly 1.4 million Canadian children under the age of six using non-parental child care on a regular basis; 57 per cent of them use licensed centre-based services as their main arrangement and about another 8 per cent use licensed/regulated family child care. That leaves about 15 per cent using paid informal providers, including nannies. Another 18 per cent are cared for by a relative as a main arrangement, but many of these arrangements are not paid and would not qualify for the tax credit.

In other words, a substantial majority of the Canadian families who pay for non-parental child care will benefit immediately from the new federal-provincial-territorial arrangements to build an affordable licensed early learning and child care system.

This article first appeared on Policy Options and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

xosotin chelseathông tin chuyển nhượngcâu lạc bộ bóng đá arsenalbóng đá atalantabundesligacầu thủ haalandUEFAevertonxosofutebol ao vivofutemaxmulticanaisonbethttps://bsport.fithttps://onbet88.ooohttps://i9bet.bizhttps://hi88.ooohttps://okvip.athttps://f8bet.athttps://fb88.cashhttps://vn88.cashhttps://shbet.atbóng đá world cupbóng đá inter milantin juventusbenzemala ligaclb leicester cityMUman citymessi lionelsalahnapolineymarpsgronaldoserie atottenhamvalenciaAS ROMALeverkusenac milanmbappenapolinewcastleaston villaliverpoolfa cupreal madridpremier leagueAjaxbao bong da247EPLbarcelonabournemouthaff cupasean footballbên lề sân cỏbáo bóng đá mớibóng đá cúp thế giớitin bóng đá ViệtUEFAbáo bóng đá việt namHuyền thoại bóng đágiải ngoại hạng anhSeagametap chi bong da the gioitin bong da lutrận đấu hôm nayviệt nam bóng đátin nong bong daBóng đá nữthể thao 7m24h bóng đábóng đá hôm naythe thao ngoai hang anhtin nhanh bóng đáphòng thay đồ bóng đábóng đá phủikèo nhà cái onbetbóng đá lu 2thông tin phòng thay đồthe thao vuaapp đánh lô đềdudoanxosoxổ số giải đặc biệthôm nay xổ sốkèo đẹp hôm nayketquaxosokq xskqxsmnsoi cầu ba miềnsoi cau thong kesxkt hôm naythế giới xổ sốxổ số 24hxo.soxoso3mienxo so ba mienxoso dac bietxosodientoanxổ số dự đoánvé số chiều xổxoso ket quaxosokienthietxoso kq hôm nayxoso ktxổ số megaxổ số mới nhất hôm nayxoso truc tiepxoso ViệtSX3MIENxs dự đoánxs mien bac hom nayxs miên namxsmientrungxsmn thu 7con số may mắn hôm nayKQXS 3 miền Bắc Trung Nam Nhanhdự đoán xổ số 3 miềndò vé sốdu doan xo so hom nayket qua xo xoket qua xo so.vntrúng thưởng xo sokq xoso trực tiếpket qua xskqxs 247số miền nams0x0 mienbacxosobamien hôm naysố đẹp hôm naysố đẹp trực tuyếnnuôi số đẹpxo so hom quaxoso ketquaxstruc tiep hom nayxổ số kiến thiết trực tiếpxổ số kq hôm nayso xo kq trực tuyenkết quả xổ số miền bắc trực tiếpxo so miền namxổ số miền nam trực tiếptrực tiếp xổ số hôm nayket wa xsKQ XOSOxoso onlinexo so truc tiep hom nayxsttso mien bac trong ngàyKQXS3Msố so mien bacdu doan xo so onlinedu doan cau loxổ số kenokqxs vnKQXOSOKQXS hôm naytrực tiếp kết quả xổ số ba miềncap lo dep nhat hom naysoi cầu chuẩn hôm nayso ket qua xo soXem kết quả xổ số nhanh nhấtSX3MIENXSMB chủ nhậtKQXSMNkết quả mở giải trực tuyếnGiờ vàng chốt số OnlineĐánh Đề Con Gìdò số miền namdò vé số hôm nayso mo so debach thủ lô đẹp nhất hôm naycầu đề hôm naykết quả xổ số kiến thiết toàn quốccau dep 88xsmb rong bach kimket qua xs 2023dự đoán xổ số hàng ngàyBạch thủ đề miền BắcSoi Cầu MB thần tàisoi cau vip 247soi cầu tốtsoi cầu miễn phísoi cau mb vipxsmb hom nayxs vietlottxsmn hôm naycầu lô đẹpthống kê lô kép xổ số miền Bắcquay thử xsmnxổ số thần tàiQuay thử XSMTxổ số chiều nayxo so mien nam hom nayweb đánh lô đề trực tuyến uy tínKQXS hôm nayxsmb ngày hôm nayXSMT chủ nhậtxổ số Power 6/55KQXS A trúng roycao thủ chốt sốbảng xổ số đặc biệtsoi cầu 247 vipsoi cầu wap 666Soi cầu miễn phí 888 VIPSoi Cau Chuan MBđộc thủ desố miền bắcthần tài cho sốKết quả xổ số thần tàiXem trực tiếp xổ sốXIN SỐ THẦN TÀI THỔ ĐỊACầu lô số đẹplô đẹp vip 24hsoi cầu miễn phí 888xổ số kiến thiết chiều nayXSMN thứ 7 hàng tuầnKết quả Xổ số Hồ Chí Minhnhà cái xổ số Việt NamXổ Số Đại PhátXổ số mới nhất Hôm Nayso xo mb hom nayxxmb88quay thu mbXo so Minh ChinhXS Minh Ngọc trực tiếp hôm nayXSMN 88XSTDxs than taixổ số UY TIN NHẤTxs vietlott 88SOI CẦU SIÊU CHUẨNSoiCauVietlô đẹp hôm nay vipket qua so xo hom naykqxsmb 30 ngàydự đoán xổ số 3 miềnSoi cầu 3 càng chuẩn xácbạch thủ lônuoi lo chuanbắt lô chuẩn theo ngàykq xo-solô 3 càngnuôi lô đề siêu vipcầu Lô Xiên XSMBđề về bao nhiêuSoi cầu x3xổ số kiến thiết ngày hôm nayquay thử xsmttruc tiep kết quả sxmntrực tiếp miền bắckết quả xổ số chấm vnbảng xs đặc biệt năm 2023soi cau xsmbxổ số hà nội hôm naysxmtxsmt hôm nayxs truc tiep mbketqua xo so onlinekqxs onlinexo số hôm nayXS3MTin xs hôm nayxsmn thu2XSMN hom nayxổ số miền bắc trực tiếp hôm naySO XOxsmbsxmn hôm nay188betlink188 xo sosoi cầu vip 88lô tô việtsoi lô việtXS247xs ba miềnchốt lô đẹp nhất hôm naychốt số xsmbCHƠI LÔ TÔsoi cau mn hom naychốt lô chuẩndu doan sxmtdự đoán xổ số onlinerồng bạch kim chốt 3 càng miễn phí hôm naythống kê lô gan miền bắcdàn đề lôCầu Kèo Đặc Biệtchốt cầu may mắnkết quả xổ số miền bắc hômSoi cầu vàng 777thẻ bài onlinedu doan mn 888soi cầu miền nam vipsoi cầu mt vipdàn de hôm nay7 cao thủ chốt sốsoi cau mien phi 7777 cao thủ chốt số nức tiếng3 càng miền bắcrồng bạch kim 777dàn de bất bạion newsddxsmn188betw88w88789bettf88sin88suvipsunwintf88five8812betsv88vn88Top 10 nhà cái uy tínsky88iwinlucky88nhacaisin88oxbetm88vn88w88789betiwinf8betrio66rio66lucky88oxbetvn88188bet789betMay-88five88one88sin88bk88xbetoxbetMU88188BETSV88RIO66ONBET88188betM88M88SV88Jun-68Jun-88one88iwinv9betw388OXBETw388w388onbetonbetonbetonbet88onbet88onbet88onbet88onbetonbetonbetonbetqh88mu88Nhà cái uy tínpog79vp777vp777vipbetvipbetuk88uk88typhu88typhu88tk88tk88sm66sm66me88me888live8live8livesm66me88win798livesm66me88win79pog79pog79vp777vp777uk88uk88tk88tk88luck8luck8kingbet86kingbet86k188k188hr99hr99123b8xbetvnvipbetsv66zbettaisunwin-vntyphu88vn138vwinvwinvi68ee881xbetrio66zbetvn138i9betvipfi88clubcf68onbet88ee88typhu88onbetonbetkhuyenmai12bet-moblie12betmoblietaimienphi247vi68clupcf68clupvipbeti9betqh88onb123onbefsoi cầunổ hũbắn cáđá gàđá gàgame bàicasinosoi cầuxóc đĩagame bàigiải mã giấc mơbầu cuaslot gamecasinonổ hủdàn đềBắn cácasinodàn đềnổ hũtài xỉuslot gamecasinobắn cáđá gàgame bàithể thaogame bàisoi cầukqsssoi cầucờ tướngbắn cágame bàixóc đĩaAG百家乐AG百家乐AG真人AG真人爱游戏华体会华体会im体育kok体育开云体育开云体育开云体育乐鱼体育乐鱼体育欧宝体育ob体育亚博体育亚博体育亚博体育亚博体育亚博体育亚博体育开云体育开云体育棋牌棋牌沙巴体育买球平台新葡京娱乐开云体育mu88qh88
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maria in Vancouver

Lifestyle2 weeks ago

Nobody Wants This…IRL (In Real Life)

Just like everyone else who’s binged on Netflix series, “Nobody Wants This” — a romcom about a newly single rabbi...

Lifestyle3 weeks ago

Family Estrangement: Why It’s Okay

Family estrangement is the absence of a previously long-standing relationship between family members via emotional or physical distancing to the...

Lifestyle2 months ago

Becoming Your Best Version

By Matter Laurel-Zalko As a woman, I’m constantly evolving. I’m constantly changing towards my better version each year. Actually, I’m...

Lifestyle2 months ago

The True Power of Manifestation

I truly believe in the power of our imagination and that what we believe in our lives is an actual...

Maria in Vancouver3 months ago

DECORATE YOUR HOME 101

By Matte Laurel-Zalko Our home interiors are an insight into our brains and our hearts. It is our own collaboration...

Maria in Vancouver4 months ago

Guide to Planning a Wedding in 2 Months

By Matte Laurel-Zalko Are you recently engaged and find yourself in a bit of a pickle because you and your...

Maria in Vancouver4 months ago

Staying Cool and Stylish this Summer

By Matte Laurel-Zalko I couldn’t agree more when the great late Ella Fitzgerald sang “Summertime and the livin’ is easy.”...

Maria in Vancouver5 months ago

Ageing Gratefully and Joyfully

My 56th trip around the sun is just around the corner! Whew. Wow. Admittedly, I used to be afraid of...

Maria in Vancouver6 months ago

My Love Affair With Pearls

On March 18, 2023, my article, The Power of Pearls was published. In that article, I wrote about the history...

Maria in Vancouver6 months ago

7 Creative Ways to Propose!

Sometime in April 2022, my significant other gave me a heads up: he will be proposing to me on May...