Connect with us

News

SC stresses rules on jurisdiction in estafa cases

Published

on

The Court said in this form of estafa, “[i]t is not the non-payment of a debt which is made punishable, but the criminal fraud or deceit in the issuance of the check.” (File Photo By Mike Gonzalez (TheCoffee) – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0)

MANILA — The Supreme Court (SC) has reiterated the importance of following the rules on lower courts’ jurisdiction, particularly in cases relating to estafa.

In a 10-page decision dated January 23 this year, the SC, through Associate Justice Diosdado Peralta, upheld the decision of the Court of Appeals in an estafa case between two parties, which signed a Memorandum of Agreement for a deal in Parañaque City for the purchase of shares in a local company.

The check for payment was presented and dishonored in a bank in Makati City, prompting the estafa suit and the parties’ contentions on whether the case should have been filed in Parañaque City or Makati City.

In dismissing the appeal, the high court, echoing the CA, said “the place where the MOA was negotiated does not fix the venue of the offense in view of settled jurisprudence that what is of decisive importance is the delivery of the instrument which is the final act essential to its consummation as an obligation”.

“Indeed, it is rather unfair to require the defendant or accused to undergo the ordeal and expense of a trial if the court has no jurisdiction over the subject matter or offense or it is not the court of proper venue,” the SC decision reads.

The petition was filed by Ruel Francis M. Cabral charging Chris S. Bracamonte with the crime of estafa and arose over the aborted sale in 2009 of shares of stock in Wellcross Freight Corporation and Aviver International Corporation.

Bracamonte issued a postdated check to Cabral amounting to PHP12,677,950.

However, when the check was presented for payment in a bank in Makati City, the bank dishonored the same for lack of sufficient funds.

The Court said in this form of estafa, “[i]t is not the non-payment of a debt which is made punishable, but the criminal fraud or deceit in the issuance of the check.”

The Court also noted that “[n]ot only were the MOA and subject check executed, delivered, and dishonored in Makati City, it was even expressly stipulated in their agreement that the parties chose Makati City as a venue for any action arising from the MOA because that was where it was executed. It is, therefore, clear from the foregoing that the element of deceit took place in Makati City, where the worthless check was issued and delivered, while the damage was inflicted also in Makati City where the check was dishonored by the drawee bank.”

The Court also ruled that the petition should have been filed only by the State through the Office of the Solicitor General and not by Cabral, who lacks the personality or legal standing to question the CA decision, especially since the dismissal of Cabral’s complaint was not gravely erroneous nor did it amount to a denial of due process.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maria in Vancouver

Lifestyle2 days ago

Upgrade Your Life in 2025

It’s a brand new year and a wonderful opportunity to become a brand new you! The word upgrade can mean...

Maria in Vancouver3 weeks ago

Fantabulous Christmas Party Ideas

It’s that special and merry time of the year when you get to have a wonderful excuse to celebrate amongst...

Lifestyle4 weeks ago

How To Do Christmas & Hanukkah This Year

Christmas 2024 is literally just around the corner! Here in Vancouver, we just finished celebrating Taylor Swift’s last leg of...

Lifestyle2 months ago

Nobody Wants This…IRL (In Real Life)

Just like everyone else who’s binged on Netflix series, “Nobody Wants This” — a romcom about a newly single rabbi...

Lifestyle2 months ago

Family Estrangement: Why It’s Okay

Family estrangement is the absence of a previously long-standing relationship between family members via emotional or physical distancing to the...

Lifestyle3 months ago

Becoming Your Best Version

By Matter Laurel-Zalko As a woman, I’m constantly evolving. I’m constantly changing towards my better version each year. Actually, I’m...

Lifestyle4 months ago

The True Power of Manifestation

I truly believe in the power of our imagination and that what we believe in our lives is an actual...

Maria in Vancouver5 months ago

DECORATE YOUR HOME 101

By Matte Laurel-Zalko Our home interiors are an insight into our brains and our hearts. It is our own collaboration...

Maria in Vancouver5 months ago

Guide to Planning a Wedding in 2 Months

By Matte Laurel-Zalko Are you recently engaged and find yourself in a bit of a pickle because you and your...

Maria in Vancouver6 months ago

Staying Cool and Stylish this Summer

By Matte Laurel-Zalko I couldn’t agree more when the great late Ella Fitzgerald sang “Summertime and the livin’ is easy.”...